Buffalo, New York is where the Buffalo wing was invented at the Anchor Bar in 1964. Today, the city takes its wings seriously, with passionate debates about which spot serves the best. Here's your guide to wing perfection in the Queen City.
Heat Levels Explained
Mild
Buttery, tangy, no heat
Medium
Classic Buffalo heat
Hot
Serious kick, still flavorful
Suicidal
Extreme heat, sign a waiver
Legendary Wing Spots
Anchor Bar
The Original • Since 1964
Where it all began. Teressa Bellissimo invented the Buffalo wing here. Tourist-heavy but historically significant. Get the medium.
Duff's Famous Wings
Local Favorite • Medium-Hot Specialists
Many locals swear Duff's has the best wings in Buffalo. Crispier than Anchor Bar, with a more aggressive sauce.
Bar-Bill Tavern
East Aurora • Worth the Drive
Consistently wins "Best Wings" awards. Perfectly crispy, generous portions. The beef on weck is also excellent.
Gabriel's Gate
Allentown • Dive Bar Classic
No-frills dive bar with seriously good wings. Huge portions, cold beer, cash only.
Elmo's
Multiple Locations • Consistent
Local chain that's reliable and affordable. Not the absolute best, but solid wings every time.
Nine-Eleven Tavern
South Buffalo • Neighborhood Gem
Tiny neighborhood bar with big flavor. Limited seating but the wings are worth the wait.
The Great Buffalo Wing Debate
Ask any Buffalonian and they'll have a strong opinion. The main rivalry is Anchor Bar vs. Duff's:
- Anchor Bar: Historic, saucier, more buttery, tourist-friendly
- Duff's: Crispier, spicier, more local, no-frills atmosphere
Truth is, both are good. But if you want the local experience, go to Duff's or Bar-Bill.
🏆 Our Picks
Best Overall: Bar-Bill Tavern - Consistently perfect
Best Historic: Anchor Bar - Where it all started
Best Local: Duff's - What Buffalonians actually eat
Best Dive Bar: Gabriel's Gate - Huge portions, cold beer
Wing Etiquette
Real Buffalo wings come with blue cheese, not ranch. Celery is traditional. Drums or flats is personal preference—order "mixed" if you don't care. And always get extra napkins.